All of the Stars - Comments

I'm so fucking devastated

@What the fuck way
aw thank you sweetheart xx

Holy shit, this was amazing! Completely soul crushing and sad but fucking amazing. I had tears rolling down my face by the end.
You are a amazing talented writer and please never put yourself down because you are actually amazing.
I can't wait to read more of your work and this is definitely in my top 5 best fanfics!
~Katie-ann <3 xxx

I am sad the Frank and Gee didnt end up together, but overall amazing story! This is my new favorite, I can definitely see myself re-reading this!!!! Never stop writing you're so creative! I can't wait to read more of what you can write!!!! :D

xojordan

For some reason I can draw a perfect straight line and I'm gayer than the fucking rainbow. But anyway thanks for the amazing story (again). I'm glad Gerard and Frank are at least happy with their lives in the story, it's nice that Gerard moved on. I get emotional easily cause I'm so emo and a hormonal teenager but you really made me more emotional than usual here. So thank you, Ioved reading that story and would most definitely read it again.

xx<3

@The Resurrectionist
I'm not kind, I'm honest. It breaks my heart to see someone so talented put themselves down and dismiss their gift as if it wasn't real. Now, I can't really talk, because my self esteem is pretty crap too, but trust me, you are very talented and all I ask is that you try to believe it. If you can do that then maybe one day you will. If you don't then you might stop writing and that would be a tragedy. Art in any format needs to be experienced and shared by those who create it to express themselves as much as by those whom it touches and need it just as much for the same reason. Thank you for this wonderful story and sharing your awesome talent with us. Sas xx

It's just after 4am and I woke up, checked my emails and saw this was updated and had to read it straight away! There was a beautiful evolution in that chapter where I genuinely felt exhaustion coming off the first few paragraphs, followed by resignation, hope and finally love and acceptance. It seemed to mirror a grieving process that resolved the further the timeline got from Gerard being 17. Yes, it was sad the way Gerard was forced to move on with his life without Frank, but there was also something joyous about the fact that he felt able to. The idea that people can come into your life at exactly the time they're needed, even if just for a brief period, but have a profound impact is an idea I truly believe in. This story has been so inspiring and a privilege to read. Thank you, seriously thank you for inspiring me in many different ways. Never stop writing! Sas xx

@MikeyLotan12
heck this is the comment that made me cry in a happy way, thank you so much i cant even express how much that means to me

@SaskiaK
thank u so much im actually tearing up from reading that comment youre so heckin kind its unbelievable

If I'm honest, I fucking hate tragedies. I've read so many of them and they broke my heart awfully, and when I read the last chapter it broke my heart more. But something about your story, just the way you described it and the way you put it out, made me just love every second of it, just like I loved the first chapter when you first started updating. Even if the epilogue is sad I don't care, I'd read it a thousand times over and over again. You're an amazing writer, you should respect your gift and love it. And this story was truly amazing, I think you would make a great author in the future if you'd want that and write actual novels, because you'll probably do great no matter what you write about.
Keep being amazing<3 Mikey

Okay, so I think I need to answer your notes first - at the risk of sounding a bit like Frank talking to Gerard - Do you really not have any idea how good of a writer you are??? This story has been awesome from start to finish - and I know it's not finished yet but I know the epilogue will be just as amazing as the rest of it has been. I rarely get drawn into a fic so intensely and it's not the subject matter, I'm not a 'ooh! A Frerard, I must read this' kind of person, and it's not because it's a school fic and I relate because I'm so far from that point in my life it's not even funny! This story was so wonderfully written and so lovingly and delicately handled that it became real to a lot of us and certainly for me. I was/am invested and that is a rare thing for a writer to achieve. You should be extremely proud of yourself for creating something that is able to move your readers in the way it has. And if you can't be proud of yourself then I certainly am! I have loved this story from the first sentence and it's one I will keep coming back to when I want to inspire myself. You should never stop writing - you have an awesome gift! Thank you for sharing it with us! Sas xx

I'M CRYING SO HARD YOU BETTER FUCKING FIX THIS IN THE EPILOGUE I CANT STOP CRYIN OH MY G O DDDD

IM SOBBING YOU CANT FUCK WITH MY EMOTIONS LIKE THIS

@legal marijuana
;)

WAIT YOU SAID PROLOGUE DOES THAT MWAN THERES GONNA BE A SEQUEL

I'm not even reading the end of this I stg. I was crying by like the third chapter cause I'm a fucking fucked up pussy omg
please excuse me I swear like a fucking sailor

@The Resurrectionist
Oh no!! That's awful (I mean, it's actually great for the protection of kids, but not for poor Frankie)! I guess he should have considered that Gee's not really old enough to make an adult decision but because we believe it's real love, it's heartbreaking. He's going to have such a difficult time in prison - he's so pretty. :'( I actually don't know what the legal position is here, I was just assuming from what they said in the story. I'm so glad it's not real, but it was/is wonderful!! Sas xx

@SaskiaK
Ah thank you for your comments I love them :)) but yes actually frank can be arrested. I'm from jersey and what the boys in this story don't realize is that yes, the age of consent is 16 but only with a person who is 4 years older, maybe 5 but no more than that. And with Frank being 18 years older than Gerard, he could actually be arrested. Also impression on a minor is a huge thing in American schools which basically forbids teachers by law from having any kind of affair with students until they've graduated. Idk I hope that kinda clears things up a lil xx

Okay, I can think again now! I could picture everything as if I was watching it happen. And I really felt as though I was there watching it, hearing it, feeling it. I really don't want them to go back and if I'm honest I don't see how Frank can be arrested. He hasn't done anything illegal. Okay, he can probably wave goodbye to his job because at best he's behaved inappropriately but surely that's all? Frankie's hurting enough, please don't make it worse for him :'( (I like Frank - did you guess? :P) Sas xx

My heart is breaking :'( I'm going to have to come back later and give you a proper review because right now, that's all I got. I really don't want them to go back either :'( Wonderful!! Sas xx